Hello friends! Welcome to another edition of FWT’s Ask an Editor series, in which I pick out a reader-submitted question or two and offer my take. We’ve got a heady one today, so let’s dive right in.

(Got a question about freelancing or the wider world of journalism? Let’s hear it, and I may feature it in a future Q&A newsletter! Leave a comment on this post or fill out this form with your question(s).)

An editor wants me to write on spec. Should I?

I recently pitched an editor for an online ‘magazine’ that’s really just the content arm of a business. He offered me an assignment, but agreed to pay the fee ($500) “if we agree to move forward after the first draft.”

I’ve been published in some of the bigger names among magazines, newspapers, and websites, and these editors all hire me based on my previous work. I’m not cool with working on spec, and I told him so. He amended the offer to $200 for a draft, and the remainder, again, if he likes it.

I’d love to hear your thoughts on this. Every part of me screams no way; if he can’t do his own reading to vet me, and out of the gate doesn’t value my work, this won’t go well. The bummer is that it’s a place I’d love to write for and a topic I am super passionate about.
— Anonymous

Oof, writing on spec, a specter that haunts so many of us freelancers.

If you’re not familiar, writing on spec generally means completing an assignment for a publication without any guarantee that the publication will actually buy it. There are lots of nuances and caveats to that, but it basically just means doing unpaid labor without any promise of payment. A variation of this comes during the pitching process, too: whether freelancers should submit a full draft of a story along with the initial cold pitch. The answer is (almost) always no: You’re doing unpaid labor on something that may never sell, and the editor wants to work with you to flesh out the idea (it’s their job!). However, there are two exceptions to that: Opinion pieces, as most Opinion editors want to see a draft; and personal essays, as some editors want to see a draft. A little different, but not wholly unrelated, to this freelancer’s situation.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Yousra S5 months ago(edited)

Absolute no from me. The time it would take for that draft could go into an actual paid commission elsewhere. After 16 years of freelancing even the prospect of a new byline won’t persuade me into unpaid labour. I sometimes do some preliminary reporting before a piece has been commissioned but that’s with an editor I’ve worked with for a long time and who I trust

Avatar

Joe M3 months ago(edited)

Bottom line: They are offering $500 if they like the piece, a $200 kill fee if they don't. So the $200 kill fee removes it from the purely spec writing category. The kill-fee arrangement is not uncommon for magazines. I might take the deal for an essay or something I was truly passionate about.

The issue here is this is a business content arm. Typically, that's the type of thing I do only for the $$. If I am doing corporate writing, it's a money job. If they want to hire me, they need to pay. For $500, a company is only buying a couple hours of my time, so it would need to be a project I could dash off quickly.

That's me.

Whether this is worth it to the OP will depend on how desperate he is for work and money, and whether the project truly is interesting to him.