Hello friends! I hope you’re settling nicely into the holiday season — it’s almost Turkey Day! I’m doing a Turkey Trot this year in Denver, so yes, I remain the obnoxious friend who thinks running a race the morning of Thanksgiving is a fun activity. Here we are.

Today I want to write about something I’ve been talking about for years but have never really put into writing: When can you go back to an editor who turned down your pitch (or even went silent on it)? This is on my mind this week because it came up a few different ways during a pitching workshop I recently hosted, and I realized I’ve never fully codified it.

So first, as with all things, let’s start with the unofficial (though, let’s be honest, official) motto of FWT: It depends. But it’s a lot less complicated than that makes it sound!

First and most important: Don’t think that a rejection means you shouldn’t pitch that editor again. It doesn’t. I know you know that, but just to get it out of the way.

Now, broadly speaking, there’s a very simple answer to this dilemma: Let a few weeks go by, then pitch that editor again as soon as you have another great story idea that would be a great fit for their publication. That’s more or less the gist of it, so if this is a question that you’ve always wondered about, you’ve found your answer! Easy peasy! Have a great week!

Kidding, of course, because as we all know, context matters with all things freelance. So let’s run through a few specific scenarios where this may apply, inspired by the most common variations I’ve heard from freelancers over the years.

The editor didn’t respond at all.

The trickiest of all, since we’re going off literally zero information, but IMO actually the most clean-cut: Just pitch again whenever you’re ready once those aforementioned few weeks have gone by. Not much more to it than that. A non-response is basically a blank slate, so if you gave the editor a reasonable amount of time to respond and still heard nothing, give it another shot. Worst thing that can happen is more silence, right?

However: If you’ve pitched this editor, say, three or four times in a row and heard crickets, your time is probably better spent pitching someone else.

The editor responded with a polite decline but didn’t elaborate.

Basically the same as above. Most often these get a generic “Thanks, but no thanks” response, which is encouraging in that it’s a response at all, but still almost as confusing as no response. So just stick with the script: Give it a minute, then get back at it.

The editor liked the pitch but for whatever reason couldn’t take it right now, OR, the editor liked the pitch, couldn’t take it, but encouraged you to send along other ideas.

This is the second- and third-best place to land for any pitch (the first, naturally, being a commission). The question here is less a matter of if you should pitch again, but when. I usually hear about this when a freelancer is pitching a new editor and gets a no but does get some encouragement, but they don’t want to seem overeager or too try-hard-y. And those are valid concerns! I fully understand and acknowledge those feelings. But I can pretty conclusively tell you: All of that thought and anxiety is solely on your side. Give it a little bit, wait for your next solid idea, then pitch away. And if the editor explicitly said to keep pitching and you’ve already got something in the tank, feel free to send it along once it’s ready. Not immediately, but that little waiting period can be a little shorter.

You and the editor have published a story or a few together, but they keep saying no.

Here’s where it gets slightly more complicated, but not much. First, you already have a rapport, so you’ve at least got something to work with. Let’s say you’ve gotten a few commissions from this editor, things seem to be going great, you like working with them, but they’ve turned down your last few pitches. This certainly does not automatically mean they don’t want to work with you again, so remember not to spiral and assume it’s over for you with this editor or at their publication.

There are a million reasons this could happen, and it’s impossible to know which one it is (nor should you be expected to). But there are two common possibilities to keep in mind, one opaque and one obvious, and they both have the same next step. (Though remember, it could be anything; these ones are just frequent.)

One is that something on their end changed. This is, again, impossible for you to know, so try not to read into it, difficult as I know that is. Their budget may have been cut, the section may be moving in a different direction, their job description may have changed, or something else entirely. Who knows.

The other is that maybe your pitches really are just missing the mark. You probably don’t know why unless they say something, so you don’t have enough info to shift gears.

Regardless, you’ve probably guessed what I’m going to say to get to the bottom of this: Just ask them. It’s best for everyone involved. If something did change for them, now you know and you can adjust accordingly, and if your pitches were just off, now you can hopefully get a little guidance on how to refocus them. No reasonable editor is going to be annoyed or put off at your asking, and most likely they’ll welcome the chance to get things back on track, whatever that may mean. So just ask.

More to the overall point, unless you’re pitching daily for a week straight, editors very rarely remember exactly when you last pitched them. We get tonnns of pitches every day, and we don’t keep a running log of who pitched what story when. That certainly doesn’t mean you should pitch an editor daily, but frequency just generally isn’t something we think about. And, frankly, neither should you! If an editor doesn’t respond, don’t get too in your head about waiting the exact right amount of time before sending your next pitch. And if they explicitly said to keep sending along ideas, they’ve already signaled they want to read your pitches again, so just send when you’re ready. (And again, if you don’t have anything ready for prime time, don’t feel like you must strike while the iron’s hot; they’ll be ready when you are.)

So to come full circle and end up exactly where we began: If you’re in this situation, just wait maybe two or three weeks, then get back at it.

Have a wonderful week!

P.S. — Just a small programming note: I’ll be taking next week off for the holiday, but I’ll be back in your inbox Dec. 1 (or this Thursday if you’re an upgraded subscriber). Happy Thanksgiving!

Oh, a few other things …

  • If you like what you’re reading and want to support FWT, please consider upgrading to a paid subscription. This newsletter exists only by the grace of its subscribers, so your help truly keeps this whole community alive. A paid sub gets you an extra paid-only newsletter every week, access to all past and future paid-only posts, 50% off all Zoom workshops and everything in the workshop library, 33% off all one-on-one coaching sessions, invites to subscriber-only events and interviews, and more. I’ve also extended the ~Fall Special~ for new annual subscribers, which gets you all the perks of an All Access subscription plus a free one-on-one pitch review (a $75 value!) Click below to subscribe, and thanks for reading!

  • I just updated the FWT Store with a few new workshops, including sessions on how Slate builds its iconic features and how to apply for full-time journalism jobs. Check it out here.

  • Got a pitch that sold recently? I’d love to feature it in a future edition of our #pitchesthatsold series! Email me at [email protected] and put “#pitchesthatsold” in the subject line. Can’t wait to see ’em!

  • Got a question about freelancing or the wider world of journalism? Let’s hear it, and I may feature it in a future Q&A post! Fill out this form with your question(s).

  • I offer one-on-one coaching! Is your story falling apart and you need a second set of eyes on it? Want a seasoned perspective on a pitch you’re kicking around? Interested in talking about careers and/or building your freelance business? Maybe just want an edit on a story draft? I’ve got you covered! Click below to book a coaching session to talk about pitches, story ideas and development, editing, careers, or anything else you might need help with! (Paid subscribers get 33% off any session.)

Reply

Avatar

or to participate